Securing Higher Grades Costing Your Pocket? Book Your Assignment at The Lowest Price Now!

Building Contract Law Case Study Questions And Answers

tag 177 Download8 Pages 1,991 Words tag Add in library Click this icon and make it bookmark in your library to refer it later. GOT IT
Katelynn Benson Student Reviews Student Reviews Student Reviews Student Reviews Student Reviews 5/5 hire me
Question: John agrees to build an extension to Chen’s house. At the time they enter the agreement, the price of building materials is increasing week by week. John is reluctant to set a price for the work until he knows how much it is going to cost. Chen agrees in the contract that he will pay John “the purchase price of materials as at the date of completion plus $6000 for labour”. The parties also agree that the work must be completed by the end of June, as Chen’s family is coming to visit him at that time. Before the work begins, there is an unexpected increase in labour costs and an equally unexpected drop in the price of building materials. John tells Chen that he will need to increase the labour component to $10,000 or not do the job at all. Chen is anxious that the work be completed by the end of June so reluctantly agrees to the change. John builds the extension but does not finish it until the middle of July. Because of this, Chen had to pay for his family to stay in a hotel for three weeks at a total cost of $3000. Chen is now refusing to pay John more than the price of materials plus $6000 for labour. In addition, he wants John to compensate him for the money he had to pay for the hotel. Required: Answer the following questions. In each case, give reasons for your answers, and support your reasons with case law. a. Is there a valid enforceable contract between Chen and John?b. What arguments could Chen use to support his refusal to pay John more than theoriginal agreed price? c. What arguments could Chen use to support his claim for compensation for the hotel?d. What arguments could John use to support his claim to the $10,000 he wants Chen topay?     Answer: The given questions have been answered below. 1. Is there a valid enforceable contract between Chen and John? Issue: The question that has been given, itself is the issue, which is, if the contract between Chen and John is a valid one? Rule:  “contract (or informally known as an agreement in some jurisdictions) is an agreement having a lawful object entered into voluntarily by two or more parties, each of whom intends to create one or more legal obligations between them. The elements of a contract are "offer" and "acceptance" by "competent persons" having legal capacity who exchanges "consideration" to create "mutuality of obligation."”- Common Law Legal System.   Analysis: the common law system and the contract law of Australia tell us that contract can be formed when certain conditions are fulfilled. When two or more parties (Chen and John), have a lawful object (building of the house extension), where john agrees to build the extension of Chen’s house (legal work) on a payment of certain sum (consideration) within the given period of time. When the definition of the contract is analyzed and the given situations is considered it can be seen that it lies parallel to one another. It also creates a mutual obligation between them which is that John would build the extension of the house within the given period of time and Chen in return will give him the payment they have agreed upon. Conclusion: the contact law and the common law give a definition of how a valid enforceable contract can be formed. And the situation given fulfills all the given criteria; hence the contract between John and Chen is a valid enforceable contract.   Case law where the offer was a valid one: Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co [1893] 1 QB 256 2. Issue: What arguments could Chen use to support his refusal to pay John more than the Original agreed price? Rule: a contract is formed on agreed terms between the parties who are getting into the agreement. Here the terms and the considerations has already been decided and no clause has been put in, as to change in either because of unforeseen circumstances, and since when entering into a contract the parties are into a mutual obligation to complete the given work within the stipulated time, Chen can refuse to pay on the basis of breach of duty or the mutual obligation by the other part (John) - Contract Law Analysis: when we refer to the issue we see that there was a particular compensation that Chen had agreed to pay to John for building up the extension of his house within the given period of time, because his family needed accommodation after that time. what is seen after that is that there is an increase in the labor costs while there is a decrease in the price of the materials required for the building up of the extension, and because of this john asks an increase in the labor price, or else he would not work for Chen, to which Chen ‘reluctantly’ agreed because he wanted the work to be complete within the given period of time. But the work though is completed has taken one and a half more months, and because of this Chen had to face difficulties and pay extra for his family’s accommodation. What we see is that Chen had agreed to pay the given price only on one condition that is the extension should have been completed by June, which certainly has not been done. When the only reason on which the extra payment was agreed upon is not kept in mind by John, Chen can hence deny the payment on ground of breach of duty of John, and can therefore refuse to pay the extra charges that John had asked for. Conclusion: the Contract Law provides provisions for the plaintiff if there is a breach of duty by the defendant, and hence gives provisions for the plaintiff to act in a certain manner when the duty has not been fulfilled. Hence there are reasons which Chen can when he refuses to pay the extra amount of labor cost as his work was not done according to the terms of the contract. Case law: for breach of duty when a contract have been formed-  Payless Travel v Baba Krupa Holidays [2004] All ER (D) 503 3. Issue: What arguments could Chen use to support his claim for compensation for the hotel? Rule: “Damages for breach of contract are viewed as a 'substitute' for performance - consequently, they are designed to put the plaintiff in the position they would have been in had the contract been performed properly. Punitive damages are not available. The loss claimed must not be too remote from the breach and the non-breaching party must do what is reasonable to reduce (mitigate) the damage they suffer.”- Australian Contract Law. analysis: what has been dis
OR

Getting academic assistance from MyAssignmenthelp.com is a wise decision. Many students, finding the answer to their queries 'who will Do my essay for cheap' are likely to find our services useful and beneficial. They no longer need to waste their time in typing 'can someone write my essay at cheap price', instead they can hire our cheap essay writers to complete the due papers perfectly within given deadline.

Most Downloaded Sample Of Business Law

Corporation Law Assignment

Download : 249 | Pages : 13

Introduction The regulation and proper operation of any company or corporation is completely dependent on the nature and manner in which the directors and other office bearers of the company perform their functions. This is so, because even though a company has a separate legal entity and it has its independent existence distinct from its members, nevertheless the company operates through its directors and office bearers and as such it is very i...

Read More arrow Tags: Australia Arlington Management University of New South Wales 

Employment Law Assignment

Download : 216 | Pages : 7

Employment Law Explain the constitutional basis for the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) with reference to the Australian Constitution and discuss the relationship with Australian common law, with reference to the National Employment Standards. The Fair Work Act, 2009 is a labour welfare legislation aimed at improving the relations between employees and employers so that productive workplace relations can be formulated which would further help in pro...

Read More arrow Tags: Australia Arlington Management University of New South Wales 

Taxation Law Assignment

Download : 449 | Pages : 9

John was an architect and was employed by a small firm in the Melbourne CBD. He worked part-time. On his days off, he enjoyed designing and printing T-shirts. He started designing and printing T-shirts in August 2009, when his friend introduced him to the hobby. He printed T- shirts when he had the time and kept them for himself or gave them as gifts for family members for special occasions. As an architect, John had excellent design skills. Mo...

Read More arrow Tags: Australia Arlington Management University of New South Wales 

International Business Law Assignment

Download : 110 | Pages : 13

Question 1 The International business law is concerned with the rights of business with each other and with international organizations. Domestic law is within the state and it concern with the rights of business within the state(Bartone, 2010). The domestic and international business law is very differing in mainly two aspects first of all the law making process and the enforcement. International law is an ever expanding field that controls...

Read More arrow Tags: Australia Arlington Management University of New South Wales 

Capital Punishment Is A Good Measure To Ensure Less Financial Cost On Government, Public Safety And Deterrence Of Future Crimes.

Download : 258 | Pages : 10

  Introduction Capital punishment is punishing of a person by the state as a discipline for wrongdoing. Law violations that can bring about capital punishment are known as capital wrongdoings or capital offenses. It get utilized as a part of social orders all through history as an approach to rebuff wrongdoing and smother political dispute. In many spots that practice the death penalty today, capital punishment is saved as discipline for...

Read More arrow Tags: Australia Arlington Management University of New South Wales 
Next
Free plagiarism check online Free plagiarism check online on mobile
Have any Query?