Post Activation Potentiation And Its Effect On Isometric Strength In Patients With Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury Post-rehabilitation

This literature review identifies and evaluates data on post activation potentiation and its effect on isometric strength and how patients with anterior cruciate injury seek post rehabilitation. This is a research-based approach to problem solving.

The summary captures an analysis of the empirical evidence in the field. Based on an investigative framework, this review delves into the hypothesis while identifying critical factors that support the argument. Mentioned are critique factors on sports guidelines and the impact of isometric force on motor control. When injury affects the knee hindering its proper function, Post Activation Potentiation becomes a solution.

Most research findings in this context focus on the connection between PAP and Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury. As a field of interest, this review looks at journal publications from sports and medical fields. These are journals on physical therapy, biometrics, strength and conditioning, and scientific research.

Through a systematic selection of this topic of interest the extraction of data a conglomerate of research findings.

Research-based approach to problem solving

Sports men and women engaging in aggressive sports use up more energy and force. Strength building is one of the tactics used by trainers for keeping fit. Athletic exercises such as aerobics, weight lifting, squatting or lifting lead to the muscle contraction. Post activation potentiation (PAP) advocates for the effective use of force during physical exercise. Sometimes medical practitioners recommend physical exercises like strength training for patients with certain ailments or physical injury.  Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) is a muscular tear or sprain injury, which may occur during physical training or daily routine. Patients with such clinical conditions exhibit traumatic stress of the ligaments (Mei, et al., 2013). Proper treatment calls for effective diagnosis and determination of the best mode of diagnosis for preventive measures. Sports therapist use clinical concepts to respond to injury and its effects. An emphasis on the extremities of a sport helps to determine the mode of reconstruction of a torn muscle from a weight effect. When an athlete experiences pain after a jump or effect of an external load, an insight into the short-term effects provides a prescription for functional tests on accurate diagnosis and future training. This meta-analysis inquires whether PAP has an effect on the healing process and restoration of patients with ACL injury.

The purpose of this discussion is to find answers to the question: “will post activation potentiation have an effect on isometric strength in patients with anterior cruciate ligament injury post rehabilitation?”

Initial research into the topic focused on isometric strength and PAP present the need for treatment technology. This varies depending on the trends in medical research. Focusing on quality assessment, systematic reviews and full text screening the research uses journals from 2012 to 2017. The study gathers information from experiments on the connection between Anterior Cruciate Ligament Post Activation Potentiation. The exclusion criteria was keen to leave out unavailable, irrelevant, and erroneous statistics. Data with insufficient information, and sampling errors was also meaningless. The method of intervention was important for prescribing appropriate action.

Sports Injury and training effects

Initial studies focused on the conceptualization of Post-activation potentiation (PAP) among athletes (Lorenz, 2011). In the meta-analysis, isometric force control is one of the motor control factors featured in sports injury research investigations. It focuses on an analyis of patients under a rehabilitation programme to discover interventions to sports injury. The inconclusive research notes that the rate of adaptation to the exercises supports research done on how PAP influences perfomance in sportsmen (Judge, et al., 2016). Strength training is safesport but acute effects of an impact are destructive. In this study high power strength training and perfomance enhancers are problematic hence rehabilitation programes concentrate on how to get the athletes back to normal after injury. Since PAP comes about dues to conditioning effects the study uses functional progression to measure sport specific perfomances. The study looks at methods used to increase strength and give power to the athlete. Important variables used are weight of the training, velocity of the process, and rate of repitition (Lesinski, et al., 2013). This descriptive analysis unveils the conceptualization of important factors but lacks a control condition for comparison. This study builds on preliminary definintion of the concept with a mention of the rate of force development ( RFD) which is critical in measuring load stimulus and contraction functions. This research identifies two PAP mechanisms for light muscle contractions which build up and an increase in strength training which influences the capacity that your muscles control. From the analysis there are different muscle fibres which bend to pressure from sprints, weighlifting and heavy exercises. This means that the type of sport determines the extent of muscle utilization hence the counter movement.

Critical factors that support the argument

Experimental research into the PAP concept acknowledges that it produces force hence the need for isometric strength assessment (Coelho, et al., 2014). In this case, athletes taking part in jumping activities, Sprinting, pushups and throwing without appropriate measures may experience muscular injury. Quick movements generate a lot of force and muscle fibers may experience slow or fast twitching. In this study, the influence made on the maximal isometric strength is the basis of the assessment. Participants in this study are 23 male volunteers who are healthy. This study explains the PAP effect through a maximal voluntary isometric contraction (MVC). It indicates changes in the development of rate of torque within the variations of time intervals. There were variation in contractile impulse (CI) hence significant changes in MVC. Although the study had a sample bias, the definition of the effects was clear in explaining the phenomenon. With intervals of 180 seconds apart, the measurement tools also faced limitations because of over estimation. Based on the understanding that PAP is a major concern in physical and medical research, the study analyze theories to explain factors behind the PAP physiological mechanisms. To reduce on sampling errors, the study focused on a target group with specific criterion of age specific, height measurements, and weight. The experimental design featured a 3-5 day lab test for criterion selection. Control groups also included climatic conditions set to prove that sports trauma could lead to muscle tears with characteristics of ACL hence surgical intervention (Hartmann, et al., 2015).

A comparative analysis of ACL rehabilitation in the post-reconstruction and conservative management indicates that ACL patients experience challenges with proprioception (Relph, et al., 2014). Describing sample population in terms of the uninjured leg, the research relies on a sample size of 140 to identify differences with the control group. Based on seven data headings the study faces challenges of inconsistencies. The use of uninjured participants as control groups to produce differences showed minimal effects at <1°. The fixed effect model worked well with the inverse variance but the data showed inconsistency in the measuring tool. This makes it difficult to address reliability in the studies and differences in their outcomes. In some cases, the rehabilitation programme came out productive while in some the measuring techniques varied, so did the joint movement and equipment.

Describing PAP helps to define some of the heavy exercises that place sportsmen at risk. A clear definition of samples in a variety of receptors clear doubts (Seyed, et al., 2014). Checking for risk factors this study proposes mechanisms that comes from the subject matter. The study uses a small sample size of 30 male bringing out a sample bias. Results prove that the factors such as non-contact and accurate knee analysis of the knee injury introduce the concept, joint position sense (JPS) and movement patterns for more ideas on how constrained position can cause injury. Such reliable control mechanisms pave the way for further research on risk management and preventive programs. By highlighting a variety of risk positions, research gives reassuring outcome with high confidence levels and a coefficient for the correlations. A series effect supports the validity of an observation across intervals giving patterns of the harmful elements such as high risk, preventive measures, diagnosis approaches and potential challenges. Hypothesis formulation depends on receptors, and implication of the injury type and such as ACL.

Sports and medical journal publications

A smaller population sample of less than 20 simplifies the research and targets a specific group (Mirkov, et al., 2017). However, this sample fails to capture quality and reliable data from different locations. Although data is a representation of the Standard deviation, it fails to address critical parameters. It highlights velocity as critical in the long-term effect of the participant’s interaction with the different movements. In this study the uninvolved and involved interaction between groups, produces changes over a period of 4-6 months. Although a longitudinal study shows patterns, is also not clear on the strong variables (Caruna, et al., 2015). Isokinetic elements do not appear significant leaving out an effective comparison. This gives the study a vagueness. Compromising the result, this study takes longer, and fails to produce credible results. A critique of the elements leavers a vagueness because it fails to support concrete variables in the question. This compromises its result and analysis as a whole.

(Singh, et al., 2014) Compares the efficacy of two different accelerated rehabilitation protocols featuring muscular strength and functional status for a random control trial. A Cincinnati knee sharing scale (CKRS) is applicable as the efficacy-measuring tool to determine the outcome of an ACL injury. Trends in this research indicate that women are more susceptible to such injuries. This disputes previous research whose sample bias featured men (Judge, et al., 2016: Seyed, et al., 2014). The study also goes further to indicate a different age group of 15-25 years with a specified injury mechanism to distinguish its target group sample. This precise selection of the sample group clearly defines the process for enhanced accuracy in outcome results. Again using a small sample of 20 participants, this group analysis shows participants undergoing a 6 months rehab like in the longitudinal studies (Coelho, et al., 2014). However, in this group the case study noted progressive changes in the sample over a period.

Descriptive results appropriately presented in the first case analysis capitalized on trapezoidal approach in which special case analysis featured to define the distributions for complex analysis. In particular, the linear and test functional approaches indicating the connection between post activation potentiation, isometric strength in patients with anterior cruciate ligament injury and post rehabilitation. PAP forms the hyperactive functions like time intervals and data processing (Trefethen & Javed, 2013). Results explain the outcome of an experiment with the exposure environment. The PAP treatment as a solution addresses isometric strength in patients because of the anterior cruciate ligament injury and the post rehabilitation process.

Isometric force and motor control

Calculations in the meta-analytical studies encourage further research to ascertain the effect of response rate, ways of coping with the injury and appropriate equipment (Bagos, 2012). The use of quality statistical measures prevented the use of false inferences. For example, instead of focusing on protocol deviations, finding appropriate response mechanism in form of joint positions. Correlational research bring out different results on the subject matter. However, in some studies it is not easy to determine the connection between important variables. The use of a sample of 20 for a study sample taking 4-6 months does not make sense. Instead of a longitudinal study, a cross sectional analysis of different sets of a population sample would produce better results. This calls for a clear definition of these groups such as participants in jogging and those in the throwing jump categories.  

Cross-sectional studies in the research analysis present conclusive observation of multiple variables. For example, post activation potentiation provides direction to the isometric strength in patients. In this analysis, PAP also connects to the anterior cruciate ligament injury and post rehabilitation. When addressing the variables, this study presents actionable data to guide clinicians who need the underlying solutions for practical application. The popularity of a meta-analysis in a clinical research makes it reliable for this study. Measuring the position of the joint and the extent of the injury brings out the relevance of comparing the risk position and its normal condition. This brings out the contact effect and the detrimental effect caused by the injury (Costa, et al., 2018: Trefethen & Javed, 2013: Hartmann, et al., 2015)

The clinical significance of the findings in most of the studies receives support from contemporary research featuring patients in age groups (Coelho, et al., 2014) and injury surgeries (Costa, et al., 2018). This is critical but a more fruitful approach compares the effect of PAP and ACL on male and females. By studying the injuries, an appropriate intervention technique becomes critical. Clinical features of ACL as an injury type describe the mode of diagnosis for athletes and non athletic study groups (Mei, et al., 2013). Studies on forceful muscular training and PAP connect heavy exercises to damaging movements. An analysis of the rate of force describes the effect caused by the rate of training. It explains the difference between a muscle twitch and a tear. Exercises such as a push up, sprint and bench press bring out the development of the Rate of Force Development ( RFD).

ACL injury and PAP

Overgeneralization is evident in studies which focus on defining PAP because of the impact analysis (Lorenz, 2011). In order to overcome this limitation, it is important to design tests that are efficient in the implimentation of  heavy exercises (Judge, et al., 2016). This gives the athletes or trainiers a guide on how to establish the distance for throwputs, heavy shots and repeated movements. Giving a definitive coclusion of the muscle effect after a physcial exercise is not enough for the therapist to find lasting solutions. In this case post ACL status indicates a reconstruction process that concentrates on weight bearing for strength exercises and countermovement exercises that are prone to risks.

Experimental designs in the research provide a solid support for the met analysis. The use of software application for data analysis produced reliable results. The Review Manager Software was effective in comparative analysis of the backgrounds details (Relph, et al., 2014: Judge, et al., 2016). Frequent keywords guided the review studies from reliable documentation for quality results. The clinical significance of the meta-analysis enhanced the findings giving error margins of 0.52°. Effective resistance training calls for random intervention depending the expected outcome. In this case, patients in resistance training will require countermovement’s that would bring the body to a positive outcome. Standard techniques give a uniform adaptation describing changes in the strength and power training mechanisms. The heterogeneous nature of this study produces variations in proprioception. Most sample sizes range from 150 to 200 patients is ideal because it favors reduced error margins.

The logic behind the theoretical findings unfolds the in-depth explanation to previous research. Based on a review of PAP and ACL, there are differences in injured and uninjured clients hence a control group would not have the same effect on both cases. This is bound to influence the outcome of a variety of (Argus, et al., 2012). From the studies, there are various injury risks, which means differences in the contributions, injury mechanisms and implications (Argus, et al., 2012: Costa, et al., 2018: (Lesinski, et al., 2013). The reference to ACL in female and male participants is critical in injury analysis because of the variations in body composition and weight bearing capacity. The loading pattern explaining the norminal and standing position also has an effect on other parts of the body such as the shoulders.

In the research findings, strength assessment is a reliable measure of PAP effects (Hartmann, et al., 2015: (Sundgot-Borgen, et al., 2013). Linked to speed and other factors, it affects athlete’s performance in sports. This insight guides the formulation of strategic fitness plans based on the neurological and morphological abilities. Its validity in assessing the other variables such as fiber distribution and power phases is effective in explaining the development of Anterior Cruciate Ligament. Clear definition of volume, type of exercise and intensity of the exercise structures the periodic programs and provides an ideal study model for measuring the post training factors such as response mechanisms, training state and individual neuromuscular processes.

Different muscle fibres and sport-specific utilization

The use of measures of the resistance and strength training exercises to check for compatibility with the biomechanical polyactivities is effective because it highlights the impact variations and outcome effects (Judge, et al., 2016). Prominent keywords revolve around anterior cruciate ligament, Proprioception, Injury, and physical therapy. Frequency and rate of these activities changes as the patient regains strength for higher training. For coherence, the studies also scrutinize activities such as weight lifting and split jumps for a healing process. Therapists recommend the right solution to be undertake a structured framework. This adds value to training procedures that have undergone clinical tests. With PAP as the relative measure for treatment in physical therapy, the conceptualization of its functional limitation and sports performance effects advocates for a cross check of the rapid movement muscle groups involved in specific exercises. This explains why complex training activities such as counter movement, and athletic jumps, load lifting and push pass cause a higher percentage of push effect (Lorenz, 2011: Bagos, 2012)

The coherent arguments support the validity and reliability of the assessment with specific measurable variables such as rest interval, strength levels and MVC (Coelho, et al., 2014: Lorenz, 2011: (Mirkov, et al., 2017). Detection of motion, position of the joints and receptors influence the stability of the ligaments. The application of mechanical loads and the regulation of the knee joints proves to have an effect on the ligament injuries (Mir, et al., 2014). In order to ascertain the claims, the proposed method undergoes evaluation for its contribution in influencing ACLR and its connection to PAP. Significant improvements indicate the significance of the functional value with mean values in control groups showing improvements. The use of exercises reveals the ability of muscles to endure training types and levels in the post-surgery status. The data analysis including the use of software applications such as ANOVA and SPSS ensures consistency of data. For example, in a sample of n=20 a p=<0.05 is indicative of the functional variations in individual patients (Singh, et al., 2014). In the comparison of results, a pre-range value highlights the difference between muscle strength and improvement with changes in making recommendations for the rehabilitation plan and clinical outcomes (Sundgot-Borgen, et al., 2013).

The critical evaluation of the fact that professionals have better training to cope with muscle constraints explains why amateurs should receive proper muscle strength exercises (Relph, et al., 2014). Effect sizes indicate that explosive force applied during power exercises leads to adverse metabolic reactions. For example, the ACL in knee proprioception highlights the reconstruction of joint position for passive movements. This paves the way for the appropriate load and conditioning used in response to PAP. The use of reviews in data extraction contributes to a synthesis of results from cross-sectional, longitudinal and experimental studies. From the analysis, an interpretation of findings indicates the significance of using different samples, varied exercises, and intensity of exercises and repetitions movements. The effect sizes comprise of odd ratios and qualitative interpretations for progressive analysis. The use of volunteer participants with specific age and biometric measurements shows the correlation between the risk position and test position. The angular error calculated using dependable variables highlights the accuracy of a recurrent limb joint movement. Notable is the occurrence of the ACL injury risk and its occurrence in a non-injury state (Trefethen & Javed, 2013). 

Importance of PAP in isometric strength assessment

Conclusions

A meta-analysis on whether post activation potentiation has an effect on proprioception and isometric muscular strength is a complex discussion. It involves clinical research from credible sources featuring sports science. Professional training depends on this medical research to prescribe the rehabilitation of patients with post ACL injuries. Both male and female athletes are prone to this risk during training. As a solution, surgical and physiotherapy training focuses on supporting the athlete back to normalcy after training. In order to obtain effective solutions, an analysis of this phenomenon through cross reference research supports the development of measures for future injury cases. In order to investigate the procioception and isometric force effects, control mechanisms come into effect. The search strategy adopted looks at six relevant journals featuring experimental designs, meta-analytical reviews, cross sectional, longitudinal study and a randomized control. These comprise of target population with stipulated intervention strategies for an expected outcome. An accelerated outcome in a muscle reconstruction plan would require muscle testing for the functional status and standard isometric. The isometric test, alternating maximal contractions (ACM), consecutive management and rehabilitation protocols are some of the comparisons used. Therefore, the research synthesis breaks down the muscle functionalities, ACL, PAP effect and risk factors leading to solutions for health risk experienced by athletes in weight sensitive and aggressive training activities.

Argus, C. K. et al., 2012. Effects of two contract training programs on jump perfomance in rugby union players during a competition phase. International Journal of Sports Physiol Perfom, 7(1), pp. 68-75.

Bagos, P. G., 2012. Meta-analysis of haplotype-association studies: comparison of methods and empirical evaluation of the literacture. BMC Genet, 12(8).

Caruna, J. E., Roman, M., Hernandez-Sanchez, J. & Solli, P., 2015. Longitudinal studies. Journal of Thoracic Disease, 7(11), pp. 1439-2072.

Coelho, L. R. L. et al., 2014. Postactivation potentiation biases maximal isometric strength assessment. Biomed Research International, 15 July.

Costa, L. A. et al., 2018. Analysis of 500 anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions from a private institutional register. PloS One, 19 January.13(1).

Hartmann, H. et al., 2015. Short term periodization models: Effects on strength and speed-strength perfomance. Sports Med, 45(10), pp. 1373-1386.

Hartmann, H. et al., 2015. Short-term periodization models: Effects on strength and speed-strength performance. Sports Med, 45(10), pp. 1373-1386.

Judge, L. W. et al., 2016. Influence of Postactivation potentiation on shot put perfomance of collegiate throwers. Journal of Strength Conditioning Resistance, 30(2), pp. 438-445.

Lesinski, M., Muehlbauer, T., Busch, D. & Granacher, U., 2013. Acute effects of postactivation potentiation on strength and speed perfomance in athletes. Sportveletz Sportschaden, 27(3), pp. 147-155.

Lorenz, D., 2011. Postactivation potentiation: An Introduction. International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy, September, 6(3), pp. 234-240.

Mei, Y. et al., 2013. Clinical characteristics of 4355 patients with anterior cruciate ligament injury. Chin Med J ( England), 126(23), pp. 4487-4492.

Mirkov, D., Knezevic, O. M. & Jaric, S., 2017. Assessment of thigh muscles mechanical capacities following ACL reconstruction using the two velocity method. Cologne, Germany, NMU.

Mir, S. M., Talebian, S., N, N. & Hadian, M., 2014. Assessment of knee proprioception in the anterior cruciate ligament injury risk position in healthy subjects: A cross sectional study. Physical Therapy Science, 26(10), pp. 1515-1518.

Relph, N., Herrington, L. & Tyson, S., 2014. The effect of ACL injury on knee proprioception: a metaanalysis. Physiotherapy, 100(3), pp. 187-195.Seyed, M. M., n.d.

Seyed, M. M., Saeed, T., N, N. & Mohammad, R., 2014. Assessment of kneee proprioception in the anterior cruciate ligament injury risk position in healthy subjects: A cross-sectional study. Physical Therapy Science, 26(10), pp. 1515-1518.

Singh, S. R. P., Arora, R., Arora, L. & Khajuria, A., 2014. Comparison between efficacy of two different accellerated rehabilitation protocols on muscular strength and functional status of the patient after anterior cruciate reconstruction; A randomized controlled trial. International Journal of Recent Scientific Research, 14 August, 8(5), pp. 1412-1415.

Sundgot-Borgen, J. et al., 2013. How to minimise the health risks to athletes who compete in weight-sensitive sports review and position statement on behalf od Adhoc Research Working Group on Body Composition, Health and Perfomance, under the auspices of IOC Medical Commission. British Journal Sports Medicine, Volume 16, p. 1012.

Sundgot-Borgen, J. et al., 2013. How to minimise the health risks to athletes who compete in weight sensitive sports review and position treatment on behalf of the Ad Hoc Research Working Group on Body Composition, Health and Perfomance, under the auspices of the IOC Medical Commission. BMJ, 47(16).

Trefethen, L. N. & Javed, M., 2013. A trapezoidal rule error bound unifying the Eueler-Maclaurin formla and geometric convergence for periodic functions. s.l., Proceedings of the Royal Society A, Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences.