Critical Review Assignment

186 Downloads3 Pages / 514 Words

In the article, Kohn (2006) has argued that homework is not only needless but also counterproductive for children. The author adopts a contextual review method to provide evidence that previous studies have not been able to find a correlation between quantity of homework and student achievement. The author believes that more homework takes away the fun of leaing which is not desirable. The author is conceed with the increased burden of assignments on children despite the lack of evidence of its utility.

Kohn cites the lack of understanding about the leaing process as the main reason for this anomaly. The author has taken an extreme stance by recommending removal of homework to increase the children’s desire to leaand discover the subject. The author suggests that the process of leaing in the classroom needs to be improved to improve students’ scores. The author has used a combination of ethos (appealing to logic) and pathos (appealing to emotions) to present his case on “the truth” about homework. While the author has raised a valid issue on the increased quantity of homework, the extreme stance taken by author has several limitations which must be considered in the debate.

>Kohn’s (2006) assertion that the studies have failed to find a correlation between homework and test scores needs closer attention. There have been numerous studies in the past (most notably Leone and Richards, 1989) who have found that increased homework time is associated with better academic achievement. Moreover, research contradicts Kohn’s nonchalant dismissal of the belief that homework yields nonacademic benefits. Numerous studies have shown that homework helps the students in leaing time-management and organizations skills (cited in Cooper, Robinson, & Patall, 2006).

However, the central argument about doing away with mindless assignments is pertinent for both teachers and parents. The improvement of leaing process depends upon “instructional time” which can be achieved only in classroom. However, this does not necessitate completely doing away with assignments. Kohn himself states that practice is needed to perfect any art. While I agree with Kohn’s suggestion that the leaing process needs to be improved, I do not concur with Kohn’s views that assignments must be done away with completely. Well designed assignments can make leaing a fun activity for students. Such assignments also allow them to unleash their creativity while leaing the nuances of the subject. However, to achieve this, the quality of instructional time must improve. This will make sure that assignments do not become a way of “mindless practice” or “rote leaing”.

In summary, the article has some useful insights for both parents and teachers. Kohn has raised a valid conce about the increased quantity of assignments for students. However, Kohn’s suggestion that assignments be done away with completely is too extreme. Kohn has failed to explore the option of quality assignments which can encourage students to leaand discover the subjects. Kohn’s suggestion smacks of an escapist tendency which is devoid of any practical application.

Free Membership to World's Largest Sample Bank

Cite This Work

To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below:

My Assignment Help. (2015). Critical Review Assignment. Retrieved from https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/critical-review-assignment.

"Critical Review Assignment." My Assignment Help, 2015, https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/critical-review-assignment.

My Assignment Help (2015) Critical Review Assignment [Online]. Available from: https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/critical-review-assignment
[Accessed 13 August 2020].

My Assignment Help. 'Critical Review Assignment' (My Assignment Help, 2015) <https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/critical-review-assignment> accessed 13 August 2020.

My Assignment Help. Critical Review Assignment [Internet]. My Assignment Help. 2015 [cited 13 August 2020]. Available from: https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/critical-review-assignment.

Latest Samples

ACC599 Graduate Accounting Capstone 2

Download : 0 | Pages : 6

Answer: Three Benefits from Going Public There are many ways in which the medium-sized company can be benefitted and three of them are discussed below: Influx of Capital – The medium-sized business will be able to sell large block of shares of the company at the time of initial public offering (IPO) when it goes public. This creates large influx of capital at a single time while the company is not required to incur debt. It can fa...

Read More Tags: United States 34 Graduate Accounting Capstone Strayer University

BHIS 515 Masters Of Health Informatics For Circuit Switching

Download : 0 | Pages : 7

Answer: Wide Area Network connects several local area networks (LAN) to one other over a large scale network. Speed of transferring the data depends on the cost of connection which future depends on the distance of the router. WAN are not managed or controlled by a single entity these are retained by distributed ownership. Wired network area allows end user to access the application, services that are centrally located (Nobre, Mozzaquatro &...

Read More

POLS7000 Writing Politics

Download : 0 | Pages : 16

Course Code: POLS7000
University: The University Of Queensland
Country: Australia

Answer: Introduction A sovereign state principally denotes to a state, which has full sovereignty over its state of matters, survival and territory. A sovereign state is identified as serving as legitimate country by other significant states across the domain. The history of sovereignty can be assumed through two extensive movements that have been established in practical institutions as well as political thought. As per studies of Nunes ...

Read More Tags: Australia West End Writing politics The university of Queensland

2103 Digital Marketing For Opportunity Of Increasing Brand Awareness

Download : 0 | Pages : 15

Answer: Discussing the potential opportunities and challenges new techniques could present to Amorespecific’s digital marketing activities Opportunities- It is certain that rapid development of technology changed the business sector by giving people a way out of every challenge in business. Due to the advancement of technology, digital media gained a huge popularity in the corporate or any business sector (Royle and Laing 2...

Read More Tags: Singapore Management logistics University of Singapore

SPST504 Remote Sensing Satellites

Download : 0 | Pages : 19

Course Code: SPST504
University: American Military University
Country: United States

Answer: Introduction In the 1960s, the period of satellite remote sensing was opened when the electronic sensors and cameras were mounted on the spacecraft. Currently, a massive collection of satellite structures exists, which effectively records information about the earth's surface. A vast scope of pictures is accessible from the satellites. Passive and active sensors, functioning from the ultraviolet regions to microwave region...

Read More