Response To Mr Newcomb Request
Firstly, I would evaluate the situation and think critically about the benefits and risks of telling Mrs. Newcomb to not arrive in the hospital as Mr. Newcomb is visited by his mistress. I would evaluate on how Mr. Newcomb would benefit from this. Also, I would consider the policy of the hospital and if such arrangements are allowed. After critical thinking, I would heed Mr. Newcomb’s request to see his mistress.
Ethical Principles Applied To The Scenario
The principle of beneficence states that the action taken in a medical situation is one that benefits all parties. The nurse’s action should promote the patient’s wellbeing in all condition. In Mr. Newcomb situation informing Mrs. Newcomb that he was busy so he would engage his mistress. According to (Brody,2014) the nurse action would yield an outcome but the nurse should weigh in telling the truth or deception would yield the best outcome. Mr. Newcomb last wishes was to see his mistress and that is what really mattered to him at the moment probably to say goodbye before it was too late. Most importantly Mr. Newcomb will benefit and this action will do him carries more benefits for him. The nurse has a duty to take steps to benefit the patient (Beauchamp and Childress,2013).
The principle of nonmaleficence states that the nurse should do no harm. Deception of Mr. Newcomb’s actions to Mrs. Newcomb would be causing her harm but benefiting Mr. Newcomb. According to (Keeley,2016) the dying process is one which includes the loved ones of a patient. This principle conflicts with the principle of beneficence
The principle of justice refers to the patient’s right to be treated equally. According to (Rawls 2013) there are several inequalities facing a disadvantaged individual and healthcare workers should be at the forefront to advocate for patients’ rights. Newcomb deserves a right to see his mistress.
The principle of autonomy states that a patient is one who can make decisions and decide on what they feel will serve them best. (Valerius,2013) states that when a patient makes their own choices they are themselves unique identity. Newcomb had made a decision to see his mistress among his last wishes and it brings him comfort.
Personal Beliefs And Values
My personal beliefs are honesty and being truthful in all circumstances. In addition to this, I believe I should not impose my own beliefs on others to negate their own circumstances. This more so important while dealing with patients from a wide background and culture. They would feel judged and in future unable to trust me hence destroying a therapeutic relationship. According to (Mendes,2015) there is major importance for nurses to understand how their values and beliefs play a role in ethical dilemmas’. Newcomb’s last wishes was to see his mistress and this would be against the values I believe in.However, after critical thinking, Mr. Newcomb seeing his mistress would fulfill his last wishes and maybe he’d communicate something important.
Strategies To Promote Self Care
Self-care is the art of promoting one’s health and wellbeing so as to be productive in nursing care for the patients professionally. This would seek to address burnout in nurses working in the oncology unit who have to deal with emotional and physical workload.
One strategy involves maintaining boundaries in the hospital environment between colleagues and patients. This ensures that there is mutual respect for everyone’s privacy and draws the line especially on what can be talked about. Physical boundaries are also important as there is common agreement between the parties on such hence less stress at the workplace.
Another strategy involves seeking help from a therapist as a healthcare professional. This is mostly because one can be thrown off balance especially because of the stressful nature of the oncology unit. The nurse has to deal with the loss of patients and breaking the news of terminal illness which is quite emotionally frustrating. The nurse seeks help from a therapist if the workplace issues are affecting the mental wellbeing.
The nurse should maintain a healthy lifestyle as a strategy of self-care. This involves getting enough sleep, taking time to socialize with friends and family and going on breaks from the workplace. This ensures that energy depleted is rejuvenated and the nurse can offer the required services at maximum ability.
References
Beauchamp, T. L., & Childress, J. F. (2013). Principles of biomedical ethics. Oxford University Press, USA.
Brody, J. K. (2014). Virtue ethics, caring, and nursing. Research and Theory for Nursing Practice, 2(2), 87.
Keeley, M. P. (2016). Family Communication at the End of Life. Journal of Family Communication, 16(3), 189-197.
Mendes, A. (2015). The role of nurses' and patients' personal beliefs in nursing care. British Journal of Nursing, 24(6), 345-345.
Rawls, J. (2013). A theory of justice. Harvard university press.
Varelius, J. (2013). The value of autonomy in medical ethics. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 9(3), 377-388.
