Growth And Development In China And Sub-Saharan Africa: A Comparative Study Of Institutional Theories

Extent to which the essay has contextualised the growth and development experience of China and Sub Saharan Africa using appropriate indicators. 

Business in Emerging Markets

In the following essay the main emerging economies of China and sub-Saharan Africa have been discussed in contrast to each other.

Through implementation of institutional theories these has led to the difference in growth and development of these economies in relation to their respective institutional theories (Kroeber, 2016). The Institutions are well-entrenched preparations and structures that are piece of the traditions or people. Examples are ready for action markets, the banking systems, customary tipping, allowances and a system of good rights.

Institutional theory bends more on the put and already established social structures. It clearly outlines the norms and practices that govern a particular economy. It also considers the authoritative guidelines for the set social behavior (Garnaut, Song & Cai, 2018). These institutional theories are the key determinants of an economy in regards to their implementation. Discussed below are China’s institutional theories that have led to its growth and development since the 1980s to present date.

China’s economy is one of the worlds booming economies firmly established as the world’s second biggest economy by means of a GDP growth of an average of 8.5%. But China’s economic breakthrough only come through during the economic reforms of the 1980s that have progressed slowly up to date.

The first institutional theory that led to the rapid economic growth and development was the reduction of the role of central planning. This was done through replacing straight plan manage with the indirect principle of the financial system through economic levers such as investment support and taxes (Yumin, & Legates, 2013). This was implemented through the introduction of the rule on Chinese Foreign Equity Joint Venture which permitted foreign assets to enter China aiding in boosting regional economies and promote regional individual enterprises and investments. Through the introduction of this law, there was ease in price restrictions which allowed companies keep more earnings and set up their own remuneration structure. This led to creation of more jobs especially in the urban centers whereby most of these industries were sprouting out. This led to an increase in urbanization as employees were now haggard from the scenery into higher paying jobs in the city.

Secondly is its marketplace liberalization institutional theory. This has established China as a major global exporter led by the opening up of the Shanghai stock trade in the month of December and the year 1990 and ultimate China’s attainment to the World Trade Organization.

Thirdly is the correction of economy imbalances. This was first done by first lying a well-planned modernization drive. This thus led to the expansion of exports which is a major foreign exchange earner for the government (Li, Ling & Li, 2012). Through the modernization drive China has been able to overcome key deficiencies in transportation, communication, mining of iron, coal, steel and building materials and development and exploitation of electric power. Also, the reduction of imbalances was also implemented on the industrial sector between the light and heavy industries. This was done by rising investment rate of growth on light industry and plummeting investment on serious industries.

China’s Economy

Additionally, was the contract responsibility system. Using this system, poor farmers from mountainous and arid areas were required to increase their incomes where they were to get profits for delivery on a put amount of creates to the collective at a certain price. This shaped incentive for farmers to decrease the cost of production and in turn increase output in the undeveloped sector (Lin, 2011).

Moreover, there is the establishment of System of National Accounting (SNA). This system made use of GDP to gauge the national economy. Through this means hence, there was enablement of numerous adjustments based on China’s national condition (Cai & Conn, 2016). This has enables the government predict on future expectations and take precautionary measures. This has enabled the attraction of more investors who feel more compelled invest in a more predictable kind of economy.

Furthermore, the incorporation of industrialization has also contributed to the fast growth and development. This is through the use of up-to-date technology, plants, light industries. The use of machines was used to replace manual labor of both animals and humans in the agricultural sector. Mining activities revamped during the 1980s saw outdated mining and the technologies for processing of ore were slowly replaced with modern process, equipments and techniques (Zhang2018). This also saw the concentration of production of the hydroelectric and nuclear power as along-term solution to power generation. Petroleum production growth has continued in order to meet the needs of nationwide automation a significant foreign exchange earner.

The institutional theory of creation of collective market financial system has also been part of the driving force behind the rapid growth and growth of China’s economy. This has led to the provision of protection of private property and overall economic policy. Socialist markets have brought about rebalance through income and wealth redistribution. Rural urban migration has also been reduced through the government’s initiative to invest in the agriculture sector through provision of subsidies and incentives that has reduced the cost of production. This has in turn attracted most of the people who have now turned into farming practices rather than migrating to the urban areas to seek for work (Wang, Wang, & Wang, 2014).   Additional, increased invest in the agriculture sector has brought about growth of rural and mountainous regions hence leading to regional balance in the economy while defensive the surroundings and civilizing social equity. Through the socialist market policy, the government has embarked on better teaching, checkup care and social safety.

Through the social market policy, there has been a substantial increase in incomes. Higher wages means an increase in social equity, social security and access of basic needs and services. In the contrast responsibility system, about 98% of all household were beneath the blame system (Besharov & Baehler, 2013). The position of free market for farm creates was further long-drawn-out and with greater than before marketing potential increasing output, farm incomes rose fast. This has led to the availability of food, housing and other consumer goods generating strong rates of growth in all sectors except heavy industries since 1980.

Results of the implementation of Institutional theories

In industrialization, a come together of the policy based on suppleness, independence and market participation has considerably improved the opportunities obtainable to most enterprises, hence generating high rates of enlargement and increase in competence.

Reduction in the role of central planning has gradually given enterprise managers greater control of their units increasing investors confidence on the business environment. This has been coupled with universal incorporation of the practice of remittance of taxes of business and firms on their profits and retaining the balance (Verhoef, 2017). The government has also increased the incentives for enterprises to make the most of on their proceeds thereby addition to their independence. Also, this has led to the establishment of interest-bearing bank loans due to the shift in allocation of basis of asset scheme funds from the government’s financial plan allocation.

Essentially, the most significant of the impact of legalization of foreign trade was the designation of financial growth zones in the fourteen biggest coastal cities-all of which were major profitable and manufacturing centers. This has made them more economically establishes cities and economic powerhouse in the regions.

Sub-Saharan Africa, geographically refers to the countries in the African continent located south of the Sahara. But according to the United Nations Development Program, the list consists of 46 countries of Africa’s 54 countries as “sub-Saharan,” exclusive of Algeria, Djibouti, Egypt, Libya, Morocco, Somalia, Northern-Sudan and Tunisia which belong to the Arab League states. The economies of sub-Saharan economies have in contrast to the China’s economy seen small alter since self-government from colonial rules, and in a number of cases some of the countries have actually experienced a decline in the GDP (Arndt, Mckay, & Tarp,2016).

This has seen the economy of sub-Saharan African countries carry on to lag behind in conditions of enlargement and growth. Unlike the boom the experienced in the China’s economy in the 1980s, the sub-Saharan economy started with a stagnant posture in the start of 1980s.Discussed below are some of the institutional theories behind the scenario.

Africa’s modern economy is comprised of exports of a small number of main merchandise such as timber, oil, minerals and the importation of artificial commodities from non-African countries. This ends up causing the countries to experience negative economies of scale. This creates a situation whereby the countries are moredependent on other manufacturing countries (Kuada, 2015). The informal/indigenous economy which has existed in the Africa for generations has had little attention from political leaders. This sector of the economy is regarded to as unregulated, subsistence-based, low-value, tax free exchanges that are elsewhere of reach of government manage and hence inappropriate for growth. But this sector is the most persuasive in African countries. An example is the Nigeria economy, of which the informal economy accounts for 75% of the service base, the biggest sub-region financial system, representing accounting for 37% of the sub-Saharan Africa economy. With little effort to revolutionize the informal sector into the world’s recognized formal sector, this economy has become vast sector sustaining majority of Africans. Due to this the regions growth and development has failed to evolve and has stagnated hence lagging behind.

Under the commercial level of the economy, rural areas are usually expected to produce agricultural products while the urban areas are expected to produce manufactured goods. But since neither of this is established, urban areas in the SSA manufacture very little while the rural area’s agricultural products are kept of the shelves off the shelves of the formal sector in the urban areas (Heshmati, 2018). All of this has thus led to poor healthcare, underemployment, declining per capital on extensive poverty, agricultural output, and constant need for assistance from other parts of the world. This has left the SSA unable to evolve beyond basic subsistence.

China’s healthy economy is one of the determinants of their economic growth hence the development factor (Mckay & Thorbecke, 2015). But unlike China which has been able to adopt some of the Western economical styles to evolve their economy, this hasn’t worked for SSA though. An example is the case scenario of countries such as DRC, Liberia and Cote D’Ivore which for some time their leaders tried to imitate the Western capitalism after which they discovered capitalism crony didn’t lead to economic growth. Also, countries such as Ethiopia, Tanzania and Guinea try collectivism for a while however they were also unsuccessful. This led to the existence of these feeble economies, constant state crises, regularly seeking financial assistance from other countries and global institutions inform of grants and loans.So bad are the financial punishment in Africa that the international financial institutions (IFI) sometimes utter what some countries are allowed to do.While China is looking for ways to make markets the main driver of development, the SSA area lags at the back in every financial pointer.

China, through the establishment of the SNA (System National Accounting) is able to measure the national economy through the use of GDP, which enables adjustments based on its national condition. Also, the opening up of the Shanghai stock exchange has led to the establishment of China as a major global exporter ( Sackeyfio, 2018). From the above cases, its evident that a country’s institutional arrangements are critical on its economic performance. In contrast, SSA slow economic growth is attributed to its weak institutions on African economies. An example are the stock exchange markets that have failed in their role of sustaining and adding value to the local currency. African local currencies have continued to lag behind as some of the weakest in the world.

Eagered to liberate their countries from the colonist domination especially through capitalism, African leaders ended up adopting wrong economic policies with the plot to steer their newly independent countries. Many of the leaders hence ended up selecting the socialist approach which ended up failing them in the long-run. This in contrast led to the stagnant posture start experienced in the 1980s by most African countries which correlated with the authoritarian and tyrannical tendencies of African leaders in the 1970s (Winkler, & Farole, 2014). Finally, these state controls for example extensive tariffs, quantitative trade restrictions, price manage began to cause chaos on African economies. An example is the case of price control, whereby regardless of how they were imposed they still ended up creating artificial shortages.

This is totally in contrast to the China’s tremendous growth in the 1980s that was largely fueled by the policies put in place. An example of some of the policies that led to the growth and development of China are first, the contrast responsibility which saw the role of a free market generate strong rates of growth in all sectors and increased productivity in the agricultural sector. Secondly, there is the correction of economy imbalance which led to a major foreign exchange earner for the government. Also, the market liberalization policy saw the opening up of Shanghai Stock exchange making China a major global exporter. Lastly, the reduction of central planning policy saw promotion of individual enterprise and investments bringing about growth to the economy. Hereby we have some practical examples of policies that continue to lag the growth and development of SSA countries.

Africa’s reliance on exports of land owned resources has yielded no economical gains for the SSA. Actually, in real sense overdependency on the few export resources has created a risk situation for the economy since any turbulence in the international markets would adversely affect the entire economy (Stiglitz,  & Noman, 2016). Resources based economies that enriched colonial Africa and the politicians and well-connected economical elite now no longer sustainable for the future of SSA.

Due to Africa’s overhang on debts, the continent has had to pay more for serving of loans than the assistance they get. This is more of a scenario whereby money is borrowed to service loans. Furthermore, funds borrowed to stimulate economic growth don’t end in that effect. Hence economic gains made are all channeled towards payment of loans making economic growth stagnant or even decline (Jomo, Schwan, & Arnim, 2013).

Africa is the only continent is the only is the only country in the world that the peasants haven’t been captured by the social class. This has made it impossible for the imperialist economic system to take over the traditional sector. This is due to the fact the formal sector is controlled by the governing elite and foreign investors while the informal sector, which consists of the vast majority is controlled by the rural farmers. This has made this case become the crux of the whole economic problems facing SSA. China by incorporating the contract responsibility system, took control of the informal sector that was previously in control of the individual households (Langdon, Ritter & Samy, 2018).. This enabled expansion of the market, which led to rise in productivity and hence rise in farm incomes. This has become the case with other economies whereby the ruling elite to make economic reforms they first start off by ensuring they take over the small rural producers and make them subordinate to demands. Independency of the people in the economic sector has continued to make Africa lag behind economically, since no economic reforms can be done without involving the majority group involved in production.

Conclusion

The business in emerging market has bee of a great impact to the economy all over the world. This is as a result of the above explanation on the countries which have worked with the demerging, markets. It is seen that some countries have failed while the others have managed. The research done showed that the economies of some of the SSA countries were at per with some of the economies of Asian. An example is Ghana that was believed to be per with the economies of S. Korea, Taiwan, Malaysia, and Hong Kong in the 1960s but is now distance past the economy of Ghana. With the incorporation of the appropriate reforms and formulation of precise policies it’s possible to change Africa’s economic growth and development to match that one of China and other leading economies

References

KROEBER, A. R. (2016). China's economy: what everyone needs to know. https://public.eblib.com/choice/publicfullrecord.aspx?p=4413913. JOSHUA, J. (2017). China's Economic

Growth: Towards Sustainable Economic Development and Social Justice: Volume I: Domestic and International Economic Policies. https://site.ebrary.com/id/11310007.

GARNAUT, R., SONG, L., & CAI, F. (2018). China's 40 years of reform and development: 1978-2018. https://doi.org/10.22459/CYRD.07.2018.

YUMIN, Y., & LEGATES, R. (2013). Coordinating urban and rural development in China: learning from Chengdu. https://www.elgaronline.com/view/9781781952023.xml.

GARNAUT, R., FANG, C., & SONG, L. (). China a new model for growth and development. [S.l.], [s.n.]. https://epress.anu.edu.au?p=244991

LI, Y., LING, Y., & LI, Y. (2012). Economic reform and development in China. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

LIN, J. Y. (2011). Demystifying the Chinese economy. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

CAI, F., & CONN, V. L. (2016). China's economic growth prospects from demographic dividend to reform dividend. Cheltenham, Edward Elga

ZHANG, F. (2018). The institutional evolution of China: government vs market. https://www.elgaronline.com/view/9781784716905/9781784716905.xml.

WANG, X., WANG, L., & WANG, Y. (2014). The quality of growth and poverty reduction in China. https://public.eblib.com/choice/publicfullrecord.aspx?p=1731189.

BESHAROV, D. J., & BAEHLER, K. J. (2013). Chinese social policy in a time of transition

VERHOEF, G. (2017). The history of business in Africa: complex discontinuity to emerging markets. https://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&scope=site&db=nlebk&db=nlabk&AN=1616700

ARNDT, C., MCKAY, A., & TARP, F. (2016). Growth and poverty in sub-Saharan Africa. https://dx.doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198744795.001.0001.

KUADA, J. (2015). Private Enterprise-Led Economic Development in Sub-Saharan Africa The Human Side of Growth.

MCKAY, A., & THORBECKE, E. (2015). Economic growth and poverty reduction in Sub-Saharan Africa: current and emerging issues. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

HESHMATI, A. (2018). Determinants of Economic Growth in Africa. https://public.eblib.com/choice/PublicFullRecord.aspx?p=5398092.

SACKEYFIO, N. (2018). Energy politics and rural development in Sub-Saharan Africa: the case of Ghana. Cham, Palgrave Macmillan. https://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&scope=site&db=nlebk&db=nlabk&AN=1608183.

WINKLER, D., & FAROLE, T. (2014). Making foreign direct investment work for Sub-Saharan Africa: local spillovers and competitiveness in global value chains. Washington, The World Bank

LANGDON, S., RITTER, A. R. M., & SAMY, Y. (2018). African economic development

STIGLITZ, J. E., & NOMAN, A. (2016). Industrial policy and economic transformation in Africa. https://dx.doi.org/10.7312/columbia/9780231175180.001.0001.

JOMO K. S., SCHWANK, O., & ARNIM, S. (2013). Globalization and development in sub-Saharan Africa. New York, United Nations.