Using two of the four forms of control (Knights and Willmott, 2012) as a framework, use any of the material in Unit 2 to discuss the benefits and challenges of these methods of management. You should also explore the implications these managerial issues provoke in relation to your own practice as a manager or as an employee.
In answering this question you are expected to use relevant theories, models and ideas from Unit 2 as well as the stipulated forms of control framework, and pay particular attention to assembling both a coherent and critical argument.
Provide a reflective commentary on the implications of Tony Watson’s article for both:
- your own practice as a manager or employee and
- your learning as a student.
Forms of Organizational Control
Knight and Willmot (2012) describe organizational control as the procedure through which the association controls and impacts the conduct and execution of the individuals from the association in order to achieve the destinations of the association. Association control is a critical segment in the administration work which is capable to guarantee that the objectives of association are accomplished and that there are no deviations in the standard execution and real execution. Association control incorporates the procedures that are intended to guarantee that the arrangement of the association and the representative's execution are as per the set targets and are accomplished with successful premise. The control procedure is not the end procedure rather at each level of the administration work administration controls is required. Directors screen and assess the framework, process and exhibitions every now and then in all administration in back, operations, promoting, producing, HR administration and serving clients. The control framework is imperative for every one of these capacities to meet the guidelines and accomplish goals.
There are different types of hierarchical control and each association receives it possess controlling techniques. Here the paper talks about the four systems of association control given by Knights and Willmott (2012) as immediate supervision, bureaucratic methods, social control and yield and self direction. These four structures of authoritative control have their own pertinence in the association to control different capacities and exercises. These procedures not simply controls the exhibitions but rather have the motivational strategies to urge the workers to meet the real level and benchmarks of execution. Here the exchange is on the two elements of authoritative control-Bureaucratic Control and Cultural Control.
Administration and Culture are the most critical and real subjects in association and administration and each of them assumes an imperative part in persuading, performing and controlling the representatives and their activities. The association control has dependably been a factor directed not simply by the administration but rather by the representatives self-direction, despite what might be expected, Knights and Willmott (2012) states that the hierarchical culture manages the conduct of workers and give them the working environment which persuades the representatives and help them to accomplish their objectives. The association control work must comprise of the control blend of bureaucratic control and social control and should be executing by administrators successfully. This would enable the association to accomplish an ideal blend of formal control with bureaucratic shape and a casual control through social to frame. The execution administration, inspiration among staff and improving corporate culture requires the bureaucratic control in the association with viable authority.
Bureaucratic Control and Cultural Control
The hierarchical control, bureaucratic control shape in the present setting in administration alludes to overseeing and controlling the execution and yield of the representatives through disciplines and rewards in order to ensure that the workers work execution, yield and direct matches the guidelines and desires of senior administration to accomplish the authoritative destinations. Bureaucratic control was first presented in the specialized control amid and post years of World War II and extraordinarily expanded its significance from that point. Bureaucratic control and alternate types of control framework contrast in homogenous component on the association control that blends inside the structure of the association itself. Unexpectedly, association structure is reliant on the way of life that the association and its administrators take after which alludes to the set practices, standards and principles in proficient life. Culture is the type of controlling the representatives conduct, feeling of having a place and inspiration towards performing in association and giving the dependability inside the work environment.
The primary concentration of the association control is to make the representatives meet the objectives successfully, spur and perform as indicated by the measures of the association. The pioneers of the organization concentrate on building up the way of life controls and the bureaucratic controls making the social standards, feeling of shared esteems, execution improvements, disciplines, prizes and evaluations inside the association Cultural controls incorporate associations statement of purpose that representatives needs to remember while working, the unwritten social standards, decorums, conduct, working morals, principles and directions including hostile to separation approaches, guidelines of lead and non-divulgence understandings, expected work routines and in conclusion the think part displaying where new staff is offered preparing to comprehend and upgrade aptitudes and learning required at the work environment and profession advancement of existing representatives. Subsequently these are the advantages for the representatives if the association takes after the correct procedure and technique for social and bureaucratic control.
The association structure then again gives the spine on which the association's strategies and work methods are fabricated. The bureaucratic control in an association in this way helps the administrators and people to fabricate the arrangement of models in the association through tenets, directions, techniques for process and confirmations. This is the method for guaranteeing proficient operation in the association through bureaucratic control. One of the disadvantages in bureaucratic control is, in the event that the usage and method is not taken after legitimately at that point there is a probability of deviation of genuine execution with the standard execution. The bureaucratic control neglects to give degree to up close and personal correspondence and to include any casual and viable technique for implementing the consistence program. Despite what might be expected the creator Knights and Willmott (2012), alludes that the bureaucratic control is a concentrated type of control inside the association's regulatory division where the lead for one individual is same with respect to the others moreover. It helps in setting up the chains of importance inside the association in order to convey every one of the arrangements and strategies to every one of the workers. Subsequently, the hierarchical structure and culture go as an inseparable unit to give the staff a working environment.
Benefits of Bureaucratic and Cultural Control
Max Weber proposed Bureaucratic administration to begin with, for advancing the uprightness of inheritance as contrasting option to arrangement of government. As per his definition the viable control through administration is by proficient information. This was to advance the benefits, evaluations, acknowledgments of staff keeping in mind the end goal to guarantee greatest yield through usage of assets of most qualified as opposed to associated which alludes to social standards, relationship working in the association. Bureaucratic type of control expresses the possibility of decency versus partiality, which expands the proficiency of general administration guaranteeing achievement of the association's destinations. It is the administration culture inside the association to manufactured the bureaucratic control that is critical to upgrade rehearses in supervision and give the legitimate guidelines, directions and approaches with the goal that chiefs effectively assess any deviation of real execution from standard execution. These strategies, set guidelines and methods are compelling when the association takes after social controls in the work environment and work morally by complying with all the important directions in administration capacities. The administrators are propelled to work in a moral and socially solid association where the association makes it conceivable to manage all the yield and execution of its representatives.
The bureaucratic structure fills the need of the association just when the way of life, steadiness and congruity exist in the association. Bureaucratic control is viewed as the formal method of control which measures the execution in connection to practices and results. The chiefs of the association admire the way of life of the association and upgrade the social control and bureaucratic controls in the association. The bureaucratic control brings about inspiration of representatives as they probably am aware their objectives and the approaches to accomplish them. The assessment of execution by the chiefs relies upon the formal trade of the composed records and data like the execution reports and working strategies. The chief in bureaucratic control of association compensates and rebuffs as rewards, pay, motivators and advancements or downgrades relying upon the worker's execution and yield. At long last the connections and parts in the association between the representatives are the subjects to bureaucratic control shape in the association.
The model of association control is of different ideas being it coordinate supervision, self-direction bureaucratic and social control, all incorporates the techniques that emphasis on improving the execution of the representatives and accomplish the hierarchical objectives. Subsequently, association control is a critical segment in the administration work which is dependable to guarantee that the objectives of association are accomplished and that there are no deviations in the standard execution and real execution. The ideas of social control and bureaucratic control are of awesome importance for the association and the supervisors to control the administration capacities with adequacy with basic guidelines, arrangements and methodology. The chiefs actualizing these types of control in the association improve the worker's execution, inspire them to accomplish the objectives and guide them the methods for accomplishing objectives with adequacy.
Challenges of Bureaucratic and Cultural Control
In the article, "Motivation: That's Maslow isn't it?" by Tony Watson in 1996 states the association administration hypothesis of inspiration, control culture and substantially more not said by the scholars but rather by the educators, teachers and the administration understudies. The article alludes to the impression of the understudies and instructor's points of view and the analysis was carried on the business and administration. For all intents and purposes the administration of an association needs to cling to the standards and hypotheses of the inspiration and deal with individuals' need so they are persuaded to perform for the association. The learning granted to the understudies in the college and administration courses according to the writer recorded to be based on the hypothetical parts of the investigation and the teachers utilize recording devices, assignments, reading material and introduction for talking about the examination materials. This primarily incited for the exchange of the theme in the class and understudies are propelled to talk about with every single pertinent point.
The article considered the motivational tests done by the directors and the instructors in different stages to accomplish the outcomes. The inspiration characterized by the creator is the primary source or the need that encourages the people to accomplish what they need through different means, inspiration is diverse for various individuals as are their needs. The significance of the considerable number of hypotheses hypothesis X and hypothesis Y or the Hierarchy Theory and Mintzberg hypothesis are connected contrastingly by various associations at various circumstances. All the above hypotheses were examined and the article recommended the inspiration through the hypothesis of Hierarchy given by Maslow as the distinctive people have diverse level of requirements which are specified in each level of chain of command. The way of life of the association administration causes the administrator to create and empower the worker's execution and adequacy. The administrators guarantee that the workers get preparing, profession advancement openings in the association alongside execution examinations, extra, motivations and advancements that benefits them and satisfy their requirements. These are the connected motivational practices by the associations in different ways that suits their business and the level of workers. The motivational learning as the understudy has been expressed with the motivational needs of Physiology that incorporates the requirement for sustenance, rest, breathing and other fundamental needs, the second need of Safety including ethical quality, family, wellbeing and necessities of work as with this need the further needs will get satisfied when understudies may get inspired to gain their living. In conclusion, the inspiration of understudies for satisfying their Social needs incorporating having a place with family, companions and accomplices will make them understand their obligation and help them to get persuaded to accomplish that which is required of them with an aim to achieve self-actualization.
Bedford, D.S. and Malmi, T., 2015. Configurations of control: An exploratory analysis. Management Accounting Research, 27, pp.2-26.
Burke, W.W., 2013. Organization change: Theory and practice. Sage Publications
Clegg, S., 2013. The Theory of Power and Organization (RLE: Organizations). Routledge.
Hatch, M.J. and Cunliffe, A.L., 2012. Organization theory: modern, symbolic and postmodern perspectives. Oxford university press.
Hewison, R. and Holden, J., 2011. The cultural leadership handbook. Surrey, England: Gower.
Knights, D. and Willmott, H., 2012. Organizational behaviour & management. Andover: Cengage Learning.
Kotler, P., 2012. Marketing management. Harlow, England: Pearson.
Novikov, D., 2013. Control methodology. Hauppauge, New York: Nova Science Publishers, Inc.
Robbins, S. and Coulter, M., 2012. Management. Boston: Prentice Hall.
Simons, R., 2013. Levers of control: How managers use innovative control systems to drive strategic renewal. Harvard Business Press.
Thygesen, N., 2012. The illusion of management control. Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan
Tracy, B., 2013. Motivation. New York: AMACOM, American Management Association.
To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below:
My Assignment Help. (2021). The Benefits And Challenges Of Bureaucratic And Cultural Control In Organizational Management. Retrieved from https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/b100-introduction-to-business-and-management/organizational-control.html.
"The Benefits And Challenges Of Bureaucratic And Cultural Control In Organizational Management." My Assignment Help, 2021, https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/b100-introduction-to-business-and-management/organizational-control.html.
My Assignment Help (2021) The Benefits And Challenges Of Bureaucratic And Cultural Control In Organizational Management [Online]. Available from: https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/b100-introduction-to-business-and-management/organizational-control.html
[Accessed 02 March 2024].
My Assignment Help. 'The Benefits And Challenges Of Bureaucratic And Cultural Control In Organizational Management' (My Assignment Help, 2021) <https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/b100-introduction-to-business-and-management/organizational-control.html> accessed 02 March 2024.
My Assignment Help. The Benefits And Challenges Of Bureaucratic And Cultural Control In Organizational Management [Internet]. My Assignment Help. 2021 [cited 02 March 2024]. Available from: https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/b100-introduction-to-business-and-management/organizational-control.html.