Investigation Of Unconventional Financing's Impact On SME Performance In Nigeria (essay).

An Investigation of the Impacts of Unconventional Financing on the Performance of SMEs in Nigeria

This research explores the various forms of alternative financing in Nigeria and how they affect the performance of SMEs. It is inspired by the challenges that SMEs face in the bid to acquire capital investment to run their operations. The study delves into the operating environment for SMEs in Nigeria to identify the weaknesses and gaps in the sector.

Various questions have been presented for the study in the methodology section. To unearth the different unconventional financing alternatives, the study proposes to use a questionnaire and interview schedule. The research will be conducted in Lagos because it represents all forms of SMEs in Nigeria. Reliability of the data collection instruments will be measured using Cronbach's Alpha while validity will be ensured by using the pilot test method. The study will be conducted within 4 months.

Statement of the problem

Financing in Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) is the lifeblood of any business venture. The availability of affordable long-term capital financing is one of the most critical ingredients that determines the growth or failure of SMEs. To put this into perspective, The World Bank (2018), estimates that close to 50 percent of SMEs worldwide fail within five years of inception primarily due to poor financing among other factors.

Debate still rages on as to what constitutes an SME. In their classification, one school of thought categorizes them as organizations with certain limits on capital investments and asset turnover that varies from country to country. In Nigeria, for instance, they have a capital investment of less than 500 Million Naira (Taiwo & Falahun, 2016). This classification has been decried among many researchers due to lack of homogeneity. The most agreeable classification globally is according to the number of people a business employs According to this criterion, SMEs are defined as enterprises employing between 2 and 100 people (Ensari & Karabay, 2014).

The role of financial institutions in the development of SMEs in Nigeria cannot be overemphasized. Firms with reliable conventional sources of finance such as bank loans and credit from microfinance institutions have a documented history of superior performance. However, only a small number of SMEs get access to conventional financing. Research in the financing of SMEs worldwide indicates that only 30% of SMEs enjoy conventional financing from banks (World Bank, 2018).

Despite the role that SMEs play in Nigeria's economy, only about 2 percent have access to conventional financing. Majority of the SMEs access both short-term and long-term financing from unconventional sources (Peter et al., 2018). Whereas data on conventional financing is available through tax returns, loan servicing schemes and loan defaults, unconventional financing and its impact on SMEs performance in Nigeria remain unexplored (Forkuoh, Li, Affum & Quaye, 2015).

This research aims to investigate the different unconventional capital investment methods employed by SMEs and the role they play in the operations of the enterprises in Nigeria. To establish this, the research attempts to answer a number of questions. The first question is what unconventional financing methods are employed by SMEs in Nigeria? Secondly, to what extent has unconventional financing affected the performance of SMEs in Nigeria? To aid in the research, both primary and secondary sources of information will be employed.

Whereas the contribution of SME to the economy of Nigeria is unquestionable, these important enterprises have been relegated in accessing formal long-term capital investment. Currently, there are over 20 million SMEs in Nigeria including the Microenterprises. The research available indicates that only less than 2 percent of the SMEs have access to formal financing (The Nation Nigeria, 2017).

While SMEs in Europe such as in the United Kingdom have easy access to credit with over 70 percent having access to formal financing (Berry, 2014), only 20 percent access finances by using unconventional means. The rest acquire finances using personal savings (Taiwo & Falohun, 2016). In contrast, the proportion of SMEs acquiring unconventional finances in Nigeria is not yet clear. What is more, the informal avenues to acquiring finances are not clear. Finally, most research has capitalized on the formal finances leaving a lacuna on the information available on unconventional financing and how it impacts the performance of SMEs in Nigeria.

Methodology

Information from SMEs across Africa indicates that over 80 percent of SMEs acquiring finances from formal institutions also receive investment advice on the side and are more likely to succeed (Africa Development Bank, 2018). However, it is not clear, how different unconventional financing methods affect the performance of SMEs in Nigeria. It is also not clear the proportion of investment that the unconventional finances account for in SMEs in Nigeria. Moreover, while in places like Asia, the finance gap from unconventional financing stands at 40 percent, the same is not clear in Nigeria.

The research seeks to investigate the impacts of nonconventional financing on the performance of SMEs in Nigeria. The study will narrow down to the SMEs in Lagos as a representative sample for the population. This is because the state has all forms of SMEs represented. According to the National Bureau of Statistics, [NBS] (2015), Lagos has the highest population of SMEs in Nigeria at 11,663.

The study will employ both cluster and stratified sampling methods to choose a representative sample from the population. The research will use a questionnaire and an interview schedule to gather data from the respondents. Both primary and secondary data sources will be employed in the research.

The research will attempt to answer two major questions. Firstly, what are the nonconventional financing methods employed by SMEs in Nigeria? And secondly, what are the impacts of the nonconventional financing on the performance of SMEs in Nigeria? The indicators of performance will be the number of employees acquired, the profitability of the SMEs and the number of customers acquired.

Both quantitative and qualitative descriptive methods will be used in the study. The study will test for reliability of data using the Cronbach's alpha in SPSS and for validity using a pilot test method for consistency. It will be conducted in approximately 4 months.

SMEs have for a long time been identified as key drivers for economic growth and avenues for the creation of employment. In Europe particularly in the United Kingdom, SMEs account for over 68 percent of employment opportunities mainly for the young generation. The SME sector in this region is growing rapidly thanks to access to long-term financing and policy support from the government (Berry, 2014).

In developing countries, SMEs are recognized from their power to spur innovation and create employment for the majority of the population. In India for instance, SMEs account for over 70 percent of employment generated in the country. In Nigeria, there are over 20 million SMEs providing employment opportunities to a staggering 60 million people. Moreover, the SMEs contribute 48 percent of the Gross Domestic Product in Nigeria (National Bureau of Statistics [NBS], 2013).

Despite the immense contribution to economic growth and innovation prospects that SMEs provide, in developing countries, SMEs face major hurdles to conventional financing. For instance, while in Europe, 70 percent of SMEs have access to financing, In Africa, only 30 percent of SMEs have access to financial support. In Nigeria, access to conventional financing is way below its peers in Africa with only 2% of the population having access to loans from banks, insurance funds or microfinance institutions (AFDB, 2018).

Theoretical Background

Access to credit means a lot to SMEs particularly in the early stages of formation. A big proportion of financing is used by SMEs to acquire human capital and technology. These two are the sources of competitive advantage for a majority of the SMEs. Therefore by denying them credit the ability to compete with established businesses diminishes considerably (Degryse, Lu & Ongena 2016; Edwards, 2018).

Historically, access to finance from formal institutions in developing countries has been hampered by a number of reasons. To begin with, government policies in many countries have not aligned with the needs of the population. Foreign funding institutions have failed to identify the key tenets to support growth in SMEs and eradicate poverty. The Structural Adjustment Programs introduced by World Bank in the early 1990s were for instance just oppressive and failed to achieve tangible results in terms of revitalizing economic growth and access to credit (Eniola & Entebang, 2015).

Traditionally, many conventional financing institutions have failed to address SME funding in developing countries particularly Africa. One reason for this is because banking institutions regard SMEs as high-risk investments. Secondly, they are reluctant to avail funds to these enterprises due to the volatility of their operating environment. Thirdly, most SMEs lack collateral to stake against loans (Forkuo et al. 2015).

Conventional institutions also prefer to lend their money to large private companies and the government. The biggest motivation for this is because the government and companies are low-risk borrowers and give high returns for the capital. This creates a spiraling financing gap because once government acquires private funds, the cost of borrowing goes up. Many SMEs are therefore left out as they cannot afford to borrow (AFDB, 2018).

Due to inaccessibility to formal or conventional financing, SMEs have to turn their efforts to alternative means of acquiring long-term capital investments. Many studies have shown that SMEs have the potential to exceed established companies in performance given steady access to credit (United Nations Conference on Trade and Development [UNCTAD], 2015)

Unconventional methods of financing are not only quick but also cheaper compared to conventional sources. While it may take anything from two weeks to a month or even longer for banks, credit unions or microfinance institutions to approve loans, unconventional financing such as crowdfunding only takes hours. Response time in business can be the difference between success and failure. The longer, the funds take to be approved by formal institutions, the higher the likelihood of missed opportunities for SMEs (Wang, 2016).

Presently, there are many unconventional financing avenues available to address past oversights by formal financial institutions. One method is peer to peer lending. In this method, entrepreneurs with solid business plans are connected to individuals who have the finances but lack ideas to invest their money (Edwards, 2018). The entrepreneurs present their business plans to the investors whereupon if interested, they lend or inject money into the business. The two parties come up with modalities of sharing business returns. Peer to peer lending may take the form of a loan but is significantly lower than most markets base lending rates (Rose, 2016).

Access to Financing

Crowdfunding is another unconventional long-term capital investment avenue being pursued by many SMEs. In this method, the SMEs connects to potential fund contributors through the internet. The entrepreneurs plead a bargain with the contributors. If both parties agree to the arrangement, money is contributed to enabling the running of the business. This financing has become popular recently with the proliferation of social media and online money transfer services such as PayPal, Skrill, Webmoney, and Payoneer. The funding can be in exchange for the product, a share of the company or for commissions when the business commences (Kshetri, 2018).

Mobile loan applications are growing in popularity. With the increase in uptake of smartphones, many mobile applications have been developed to extend emergency loan facilities to SMEs who hitherto would be locked out of formal credit facilities (UNCTAD, 2015). The mobile applications in many parts of Africa are off the grid and often not regulated by the central banks. The credit providers are either local or foreign often times requiring no collateral. Some of the common mobile money loan providers include Okash which extends credit facilities to borrowers through the internet (Ibidduni et al., 2018).

The next unconventional financing is trust funds. The idea behind trust funds is to facilitate the growth of SMEs by providing them with rotational credit facilities. These funds usually target specific groups within the population such as the youth and women. They have low interest and mostly have a capped ceiling to ensure that the most vulnerable groups take full advantage. Trust funds achievement in invigorating SMEs is somewhat of a mixed bag. In the past, they took the form of Development Finance Institutions (DFI) which were not successful (Kumaran, 2015).

Today, many trust funds are providing a lifeline to countless SMEs across Africa. Countries like Kenya, the Youth Enterprise Fund has assisted many young people to establish businesses. In Nigeria, the Lagos Enterprise Trust Fund has facilitated the inception and running of over 3000 business ventures (The Nation Nigeria, 2017).

Next, the paper explores blockchain financing. This is a relatively new technology with a history spanning over the past 10 years. In this unconventional funding, many entrepreneurial persons buy the blockchain currency when during the low seasons and basically speculate over a couple of years. Many SMEs have been established with proceeds of blockchain technology such as bitcoins, litecoins, and Ethereum. It can be a risky capital venture due to the unpredictability of the market (Patwardhan, 2016).

Trade credit is another unconventional method of financing employed by SMEs. In this method, an SME forms a partnership with other businesses in the market. An agreement is reached where the SME benefits by licensing its products or services to another firm at a fee. Trade credit may also take the form of alliances where one business provides services for another in exchange for business commissions or concessions (Moreira, 2016).

Difficulty in Acquiring conventional financing

The ability of SMEs in Africa to acquire formal loans can be attributed to among other factors, lack of information on business roles of the SMEs, a high cost of borrowing exacerbated by Government appetites for private funding and lastly corruption. A study done by the Africa Development Bank (2018) indicated that only 9 percent of SMEs in Africa have access to formal financing. In contrast, a study done by World Bank (2018) indicated that 45 percent of South American SMEs have access to conventional financing and over 70 percent of SMEs are financed by bank loans in Europe.

In Nigeria, the National Bureau of Statistics (2015) indicated that less than 2 percent of SMEs have access to conventional financing. This leaves a huge financial gap in facilitating the operations of SMEs. Studies conducted on the availability of loans for SMEs in Africa generally indicated that it was less likely for the firms to acquire loan facilities than in other developing countries (Quartey, Turkson, Abor & Iddrisu, 2017).

With the cost of capital investment rising over the last decade due to among other factors, financial crisis and fluctuations in world markets, many SMEs have turned to nonconventional financing to fund their operations. In Europe, a study by Berry (2015) indicated that over 30% of businesses were considering alternative funding due to high-interest rates. In Africa, as high as 90% of SMEs have thrived by using alternative forms of financing due to inaccessibility of formal channels (Forkuoh et al., 2015).

Studies done in Africa indicate that South Africa and Kenya are leading in peer to peer business financing. In the year 2016 for instance, South Africa raised 17 million USD for financing SMEs while Kenya followed closely by raising 15 million USD. In Europe, UK is leading in this financing while Israel and China lead in the Middle East and Asia-Pacific respectively (Patwardhan, 2018).

In Africa, other active member countries include Nigeria which uses P2P online lending platform hosted by the United Kingdom. Egypt and Morocco use both the online platform from UK and Australia. The Platform is growing rapidly and will likely be a model for external capital investment in Africa providing the much-needed finances to SMEs that find bank loans unaffordable. The biggest barrier to Peer to Peer financing is that all the operating platforms are based outside Africa. However, there are plans to venture into Africa following a successful business in the past few years (Allen, Qian & Xie, 2018).

Despite many studies done in Africa, the full extent to the adoption of Peer to Peer lending in Nigeria has not been explored. It is not established the extent to which Peers to Peer financing has affected the performance of SMEs not just in Nigeria but also in Africa as most studies focused on the scale of adoption for the technology (Ensari & Karabay, 2014).

Crowdfunding has grown considerably in the last five years in Africa due to increased internet uptake and availability of smartphones. Research indicates that over 60% of the crowdfunding fall within the service sector with social ventures having the highest success (Kumaran, 2015).

In Africa, the most popular crowdfunding platforms include AfrikStart and Jamii East Africa crowdfunding platform. Just like in Africa, the most active crowdfunding platforms across the world are focused on social ventures with the ability to impact the greatest number of people. Research on crowdfunding focuses more on social aspects and the business aspect is yet to be explored (Kshetri, 2018; Ibidunni et al., 2018)

Trading in cryptocurrency has become very popular because of the huge potential to gather capital investments in a relatively shorter period as compared to investing in shares, the money market or treasury bonds. Research shows that 84 percent of businesses across the world have either made or are in the process of making plans to adopt blockchain technology for financing their operations (Degryse, et al., 2016).

Block Chain technology is still relatively a nascent field that is yet to be explored on the potential for alternative financing in Africa. Studies were done in West Africa, East Africa, and South Africa to indicate that 70 percent of the users have been able to build credit reputation and are the new targets for SME lending whom banks and microfinance institutions avoided in the past.

With the exception of bank loans, trade credit is the second most highly rated source of financing for SMEs. Studies that were done previously indicate that over 20% of SMEs across the world use trade credit as a source of business finance. What is more, previous research posits that trade credit has the potential to grow business by over 40% in Europe and Asia. This form of financing can be very useful in Africa where customers lack the means of paying for goods and services upfront (Rose, 2016).

The customers form partnerships with the SMEs to avail the funds for goods and services used after an agreed period. Most research in financing in Africa has been limited to Bank loans leaving a gap on the potential of this unconventional financing to impact on the performance of SMEs in Africa.

Trust funds have been utilized in many parts of Africa to spur economic growth and revitalize the SMEs. In the 1990s, the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund oversaw the election of Development Financial Institutions whose sole mandate was to boost agribusiness enterprises. Though many of these DFIs failed due to mismanagement and loan defaults in Africa, they provided a critical model for later execution in most African countries (Quartey et al., 2017)

In East Africa, Kenya and Uganda have Youth Enterprise Funds. In addition, Kenya has Women enterprise fund which targets women SMEs. These trust funds have been relatively successful and latest studies show that the SMEs operated using these funds are 20% more likely to succeed than SMEs using other methods of nonconventional financing. This is because of the financial advice that is given prior to acquiring the fund (AFDB, 2018).

In Nigeria, a study by the National Bureau of Statistics (2015) found that Lagos Enterprise Trust Fund has enabled successful inception and operations of over 3000 SMEs. The fund has a lower interest rate of 4% compared to banks with base lending rates of over 16%. The extent to which trust funds impact SME performance remains a green area as most studies focus on its availability to SMEs.

This form of SME financing is practiced in select African Countries. The idea behind this model of long-term financing is that a group of people come together and decide to make contributions to a common cause. The group agrees to meet at a specified time each month or sooner at one of the participants home. The contributions are thereby made to each group member in an alternating manner. In certain regions such as East Africa, they are called "Merry-go-rounds" or "Chamas" whereas In Ghana the group is called "Susu". The funds are mostly used to establish an SME. It is a very effective method because the funds are not tied to any interest rate (Forkuoh  et al., 2015).

In this form of financing, an SME enters into an agreement with another business preferably an established entity. Within the agreement, the SME agrees to provide its product or service under license for a fee. This agreement is bound by time. After an agreed period has elapsed, the SME can either agree to renew its contract or continue its operations on its own. This mode of financing has been practiced in many parts of the world among startups (Rose, 2016).

Inheritance is one of the most common methods of unconventional business financing in Africa. In this method, all obligations to run an existing business are bequeathed upon a successor when the patron or matron of an estate passes on. Inheritance involves laws and customs practices in many parts of Africa. Many societies forbid extended members from the inheritance. Upon meeting the requirements portrayed by the patron, matron and society customs the successor may feel obligated to start an SME using proceeds from the inheritance (Forkuoh et al., 2015).

The study will help to unveil the most effective method of unconventional financing in Nigeria. Since the study will use both qualitative and quantitative descriptive techniques, it aims to unveil new gaps present in the market for further research. Most importantly, the study aims to find out the extent to which alternative financing can improve business profitability and growth. Finally, the research is important because it adds new information to the finance body of knowledge in Nigeria.

Conclusion

This study focuses on the alternative methods to the financing of SMEs other than the conventional financing methods in the industry. It also proposes to explore the impacts of unconventional financing on the performance of SMEs in Nigeria. The study will be conducted in Lagos. The study will explore alternative financing methods such as peer to peer lending, crowdfunding, trade credit, blockchain technology, rotational savings and strategic alliances as the independent variables. Performance indicators include profitability and number of employees. Both qualitative and quantitative methods will be employed. The study will narrow down to Lagos since the city represents all types of SMEs. To collect data, a questionnaire and an interview schedule will be utilized. The proposed period to undertake the study is 4 months.

References

Africa Development Bank. (2018). African Guarantee Fund for Small and Medium-sized Enterprises [African Development Bank]. Retrieved December 14, 2018, from https://www.afdb.org/en/topics-and-sectors/initiatives-partnerships/african-guarantee-fund-for-small-and-medium-sized-enterprises/

Allen, F., Qian, M., & Xie, J. (2018). Understanding informal financing. Journal of Financial Intermediation, 29–32.

Berry, F. (2014, November 7). UK alternative finance market set to surge in 2015 - study. Reuters. Retrieved from https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-britain-financing-study-idUKKBN0IR00O20141107

Degryse, H., Lu, L., & Ongena, S. (2016). Informal or formal financing? Evidence on the co-funding of Chinese firms. Journal of Financial Intermediation, 27(2016), 31–50. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfi.2016.05.003

Edwards, C. (2018). Alternative Financing Methods for Startups [Business News Daily]. Retrieved December 11, 2018, from https://www.businessnewsdaily.com/1733-small-business-financing-options-.html

Eniola, A. A., & Entebang, H. (2015). SME Firm Performance-Financial Innovation and Challenges. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 195(2015), 334–342.

Ensari, M. S., & Karabay, M. E. (2014). What Helps to Make SMEs Successful in Global Markets? Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 150(2014), 192–201.

Forkuoh, S. K., Li, Y., Affum, O. E., & Quaye, I. (2015). Informal Financial Services, a Panacea for SMEs Financing? A Case Study of SMEs in the Ashanti Region of Ghana. American Journal of Industrial and Business Management, 5(2015), 779–792.

Ibidunni, A. S., Kehinde, O. J., Ibidunni, O. M., Olokundun, M. A., Olubusayo, F. H., Salau, O. P., … Fred, P. (2018). Data on the relationships between financing strategies, entrepreneurial competencies and business growth of technology-based SMEs in Nigeria. Data in Brief, 18(2018), 988–991.

Kshetri, N. (2018). Informal Institutions and Internet-based Equity Crowdfunding. Journal of International Management, 24(1), 33–51.

Kumaran, S. (2015, June 18). Sources of Short-Term and Long-Term Financing for Working Capital. Retrieved December 11, 2018, from https://www.invensis.net/blog/finance-and-accounting/sources-of-short-term-and-long-term-financing-for-working-capital/

Moreira, D. F. (2016). The Microeconomic Impact on Growth of SMEs When the Access to Finance Widens: Evidence from Internet & High-tech Industry. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 220(2016), 278–287.

National Bureau of Statistics. (2013). SMEDAN and National Bureau of Statistics Collaborative Survey:  Selected Findings on SMEs in Nigeria (pp. 5–20). Lagos: NBS.

Patwardhan, A. (2018). Chapter 18 - Peer-To-Peer Lending. In Handbook of Blockchain, Digital Finance, and Inclusion, Volume 1 (pp. 389–418). Cambridge: Academic Press.

Peter, F. O., Oladele, P., Adegbuyi, O., Olokundun, A. M., Peter, A. O., Amaihian, A. B., … Salau, O. P. (2018). Data set on training assistance and the performance of small and medium enterprises in Lagos, Nigeria. Data in Brief, 19(2018), 2477–2480.

Quartey, P., Turkson, E., Abor, J. Y., & Iddrisu, A. M. (2017). Financing the growth of SMEs in Africa: What are the contraints to SME financing within ECOWAS? Review of Development Finance, 7(1), 18–28.

Rose, J. (2016). 10 Ways to Invest That Don’t Involve the Stock Market [The Huffington Post]. Retrieved December 11, 2018, from https://www.huffingtonpost.com/jeff-rose/10-ways-to-invest-that-do_b_7942682.html

Taiwo, J. N., & Falohun, T. O. (2016). SMEs Financing and its Effects on Nigerian Economic Growth. European Journal of Business, Economics and Accountancy, 4(4), 37–48.

The Nation Nigeria. (2017, December 9). The challenges of SMEs in Nigeria. Retrieved December 16, 2018, from https://thenationonlineng.net/challenges-smes-nigeria/

UNCTAD. (2015). Improving the Competitiveness of SMEs in Developing Countries: The Role of Finance To Enhance Enterprise Development (pp. 10–51). New York: United Nations Conference on Trade and Development.

Wang, Y. (2016). What are the biggest obstacles to growth of SMEs in developing countries? – An empirical evidence from an enterprise survey. Borsa Istanbul Review, 16(3), 167–176.

World Bank. (2018). SME Finance: Improving SMEs’ access to finance and finding innovative solutions to unlock sources of capital. [World Bank]. Retrieved December 16, 2018, from https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/smefinance