The initial premise of the argument says that the fundamental Management concept of the Liberal humanitarians about Burqa is not acceptable as they only views the presence of Burqa to be a symbol of female repression and an example of the cultural diversity in Australia. According to the argument, the aforementioned perceptions should not be considered with high amount of priority though have not given any firm explanation about why the views should not be considered. Further, the assertion presented by the first premise regarding the greatness of the nation is rather vague, as it does not stand for any particular meaning. However, the most significant and considerable fact presented by the premise is that there is a growing awareness among the fair-minded Australians who believe that Burqa is a threat for the society.
The second premise asserts with evidence that Burqa has now become a successful veil for committing crimes. The case of robbing in Mainbrace provides enough proof of the fact that through wearing Burqa people are now deceiving themselves and attempting criminal acts. However, the evidence is not as stronger as required to establish the fact that Burqa has become a tool for crime because the readers require more such evidences. Therefore, the generalization is not proved potential to contemplate that Burqa has become a threat though it is a fact worth admitting that the attempt to make disguise with the apparel has made it difficult for the Police to catch the criminals. Moreover, the claim that police department is now in need of political power needs more explanation and evidences from other cases.
The third premise presents relatively stronger approach as it talks about the negativity brought by Burqa and its purpose and its potentiality to impose harm on the core Australian value. However, it is to argue also that while talking about core values of Australia, there should have been mentions of some of the fundamental socio-cultural values of Australia. The argument has only mentioned that the equality of women is one of the core values of Australia. The particular statement requires more evidences and constitutional supporting statements. However, the argument has asserted a very fundamental fact that says immigrants should not recreate their own values and embrace the culture of the foreign nation. However, the argument that burqa has become a predicament for the integration is not completely acceptable, as no supportive statement has given about the fact that the Muslim inhabitants of Australia are opposing other Australian constitutions.
The final premise interprets a poll result though in a brief manner, which is not expected. However, the interpretation is relevant as per the reason that the result that indicates that 81% of the Australians are against Burqa, therefore it should be banned.
The argument presented under the name “Ban the Burqa” asserts that there is an immediate need to ban the apparel called – Burqa as it suppress women empowerment and has become a convenient veil for committing criminal acts. There has been found several chosen language and rhetoric while presenting the argument. Moreover, fallacious language games have been also there in the argument. In the initial paragraphs, there are some annoying words like “Liberal do-gooders”, which directly attacks the Management philanthropists and their humanitarian concepts. The categorization of the word falls under the “argumentum ad hominem” fallacy and it has helped the argument to oppose the mindset of those who have a somewhat optimistic opinion about Burqa. On the other hand, by putting words like “fair-minded Asutralians”, which falls under the argumentam ad populam fallacy, the argument is indicative of the fact that those who think Burqa is not a piece of threat are not fair minded.
Most significantly, the third paragraph suffers from the particular fallacy of oversimplification. It is because the paragraph has generalized the fact that he Burqa is an aspect of repression though the argument should have considered the fact that not all Muslim women are forced to wear the apparel. The oversimplification has been misused, as there is the need to consider the fact that there are several women who wear the apparel by their own consent. Moreover, there can be seen use of varied vague, equivocal as well as emotional words like “wishy-washy”, “great nation” and “old world”. At the same time, there are found two more fallacies, which are “circular reasoning” and “begging the question”, through which, the argument has asserted that the multicultural society of Australia is great without the potential contribution made within the nation. The language that is full of vague and unnecessary emotional words have been supported by lack of evidences has made the argument biased and less relevant.
The present segment will pursue a brief report on the study of Roy Morgan and the poll result brought by it and the use of the result by Advance Australia. The survey result have been issued in the Roy Morgan website on 6 August 2010.
The survey has been conducted upon only 434 people or 0.002% population of Australia. The sample size is not only disappointing but also there has been no mention of the fact that the sample size is homogenous or not.
The survey information only indicated that the survey has been conducted through messages and there has been no mention about the particular way of selecting the sample size and the reason behind it. Most significantly, there is no mention either about the fact that whether any differentiation has been made between the urban and rural respondents of Australia or not.
In terms of measurement instrument, the survey has used two questions – “Should women be allowed to wear a burqa in the public places?” and “Should women be allowed to wear a burqa when giving evidence in court”. The questions do not match properly with each other as per the purpose. Both the questions serve a same purpose and the differentiation between public place and court is not acceptable.
There has been made no clarification of the fact that whether the all the respondents have been “Australian citizens” or not. Moreover, Burqa has been generalized and any proper form of the apparel has not been mentioned. Therefore, consequently the poll has acquired a fallacious generalization, which is not expected.
As the sample size is not acceptable to determine that Burqa is a social issue, the Advance Australia should not have used the result. Because of the flawed generalization made in the survey, the argument of Advance Australia has also reached to a vague and hasty result.
The rising tension regarding the Muslim and Middle Eastern migrants has not in the Management Mainbrace area has been the primary reason for the political group – “Advance Australia” to run a campaign against Burqa. The following section is attempting to provide recommendations considering the fallacies present in the argument.
There is a need to have a justifiable liberal perspective on the apparels of Burqa and the culture related to it. Therefore, it would be best; if there will be an expression that will say that Burqa banning would not force the criminals in discarding their appearance (Barker 2016). Moreover, in order to establish the aforementioned expression, a proper survey should be done. If there has been done no such proper, survey yet instead of the study of Roy Morgan, then the emphasis should center on more relevant information related to the issues brought by Burqa (Baehr and Gordon 2013).
Baehr, P. and Gordon, D., 2013. From the headscarf to the burqa: the role of social theorists in shaping laws against the veil. Economy and Society, 42(2), pp.249-280.
Barker, R., 2016. Rebutting the Ban the Burqa Rhetoric: A Critical Analysis of the Management Arguments for a Ban on the Islamic Face Veil in Australia. Adel. L. Rev., 37, p.191.
Gray, A., 2014. The Manifestation of Religious Belief Through Dress. European Journal of Law Reform, 16, p.2.
Aph.gov.au. 2017. Muslim Australians – Parliament of Australia. [online] Available at: https://www.aph.gov.au/About_Parliament/Parliamentary_Departments/Parliamentary_Library/Publications_Archive/archive/MuslimAustralians [Accessed 15 May 2017].
Baehr, P. and Gordon, D., 2013. From the headscarf to the burqa: the role of social theorists in shaping laws against the veil. Economy and Society, 42(2), pp.249-280.
Barker, R., 2016. Rebutting the Ban the Burqa Rhetoric: A Critical Analysis of the Arguments for a Ban on the Islamic Face Veil in Australia. Adel. L. Rev., 37, p.191.
En.wikipedia.org. 2017. Types of hijab. [online] Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Types_of_hijab [Accessed 15 May 2017].
Gray, A., 2014. The Manifestation of Religious Belief Through Dress. European Journal of Law Reform, 16, p.2.
Levey, G.B., 2015. Secularism as proto-multiculturalism: the case of Australia.
Williams, R.R., 2015. WHY STUDY RELIGION VISUALLY?. Seeing Religion: Toward a Visual Sociology of Religion, 146, p.192.
To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below:
My Assignment Help. (2018). Critical Analysis Of Arguments System. Retrieved from https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/critical-analysis-of-arguments-system.
"Critical Analysis Of Arguments System." My Assignment Help, 2018, https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/critical-analysis-of-arguments-system.
My Assignment Help (2018) Critical Analysis Of Arguments System [Online]. Available from: https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/critical-analysis-of-arguments-system
[Accessed 22 January 2021].
My Assignment Help. 'Critical Analysis Of Arguments System' (My Assignment Help, 2018) <https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/critical-analysis-of-arguments-system> accessed 22 January 2021.
My Assignment Help. Critical Analysis Of Arguments System [Internet]. My Assignment Help. 2018 [cited 22 January 2021]. Available from: https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/critical-analysis-of-arguments-system.
MyAssignmenthelp.com is a reputed name in the domain of providing assignment writing services in Australia. Our wider range of services includes college assignment help, university assignment help as well as high school assignment help. Students from any background or at any level, can avail our assignment writing help for best results. Our assignment experts, writers and editors work as a team to provide students top-quality assignment help that can get them higher grades.
Answer Annotated Bibliography Article 1 Citation Lu, T. H., Lin, H. C., Chen, R. R., & Chen, Y. L. (2013). Motion-Sensing Based Management System for Smart Context-Awareness Rehabilitation Healthcare. Advances in Internet of Things, 3(02), 1. Summary This paper is completely based on the motion sensing based management process and in which the author explained different balance exercis...
Read MoreAnswer Reflective journal The paper will evaluate different facts regarding why the communication skills is consideredas being one of the difficult processes especially for people from different cultures. As I belong to a different country which means a different culture, language, and a different living style therefore,I have facedcommunication problems during the first year of my college in Dublin. Due to this problem, I was unable to make ...
Read MoreAnswer: Importance of the project Business management is a set of doable that must be performed before initiating the project for achieving better results. This report will discuss about issues and problems that Coca Cola faces while performing business management. This report will also discuss about the opportunities Coca Cola will enjoy during their expansion. SMART objectives of Coca Cola is also discussed in this report. SMA...
Read MoreAnswer: Introduction 3D printing refers to the process of creating 3D solid objects from digital files. The development of a 3D printed object is usually obtained by use of the additive process. In this process an object is developed by laying down successive layers of material until the object is created. All this layers can be seen as individual thinly sliced horizontal cross-section of the eventual object. How 3D printer works The proces...
Read MoreAnswer: This Assessment Booklet provides you with information and your assessment tasks for this unit. A requirement of your qualification, from which the unit of competence is taken, is the application of the concepts you have been learning.The assessment activities are an important part of your course as they provide an opportunity to apply what you have been learning and they give both you and your trainer feedback on your progress. ...
Read MoreJust share requirement and get customized Solution.
Orders
Overall Rating
Experts
Our writers make sure that all orders are submitted, prior to the deadline.
Using reliable plagiarism detection software, Turnitin.com.We only provide customized 100 percent original papers.
Feel free to contact our assignment writing services any time via phone, email or live chat. If you are unable to calculate word count online, ask our customer executives.
Our writers can provide you professional writing assistance on any subject at any level.
Our best price guarantee ensures that the features we offer cannot be matched by any of the competitors.
Get all your documents checked for plagiarism or duplicacy with us.
Get different kinds of essays typed in minutes with clicks.
Calculate your semester grades and cumulative GPa with our GPA Calculator.
Balance any chemical equation in minutes just by entering the formula.
Calculate the number of words and number of pages of all your academic documents.
Our Mission Client Satisfaction
it was really good and i will recomend it to my friends. i got above average marks for it
Australia
Dear Sir/Madam, Thank you very much for your expertise and assistance. I was very informative and very helpful. Regards,
Australia
Dear Sir/Madam, Thank you very much for the excellent work! It really helped me a lot. Regards,
Australia
the best team ever and very timely manners with affordable pricing and won’t have any complaints
Australia